Donna Forex Forum

Systems (EA's and manual), and Managed Accounts => EA's (automated systems), and associated items (VPS, support/questions) => Topic started by: donnaforex on February 17, 2017, 12:10:16 PM

Title: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on February 17, 2017, 12:10:16 PM
I have locked the old FRPEA topic as it is very old and over 50 pages long. If you want to view it, you can view it here. (http://donnaforex.com/index.php?topic=3116)


Please use this new topic to discuss FRPEA.

Incredibly, this EA now has over 7 years of live forward test, myfxbook verified results!

Visit the FRPEA website: here (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor.c2strack.com)

FRPEA have offered forum members a 10% discount on their purchase. You can get it by going to this link (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.c2strack.com/?checkout) (goes direct to shopping cart)

I have set up a forum account live test on myfxbook:

(https://donnaforex.com/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fwidgets.myfxbook.com%2Fwidgets%2F1986442%2Flarge.jpg&hash=4942ad82e1085f7bbcf9e6ce0c7f5b3d) (http://www.myfxbook.com/members/donnaforexreal/forexrealprofitea/1986442)
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: prabincr on February 17, 2017, 03:55:35 PM
For the best trading deals and options, I recommend you to try this out. This site taught me a lot about trading TRADING SIGNALS:  ***removed ad: donnaforex***
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on February 17, 2017, 03:59:58 PM
I recommend you stop trying to spam our forum with ads for your broker, you might end up getting the wrong sort of exposure in a 'hall of shame'
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: impifx on February 19, 2017, 11:37:01 AM
I will try this. Hopefully it will be a good team together with CabEX.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on February 19, 2017, 12:00:10 PM
let us know how you get on :). I have high hopes for this one, i don't know of any other EA's with a 7 year track record yet!
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: nck on February 22, 2017, 04:58:17 PM
let us know how you get on :). I have high hopes for this one, i don't know of any other EA's with a 7 year track record yet!
thanks for the testing donna
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: bleach on February 24, 2017, 12:55:11 PM
Interesting will take a deeper look
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: reinerh on February 24, 2017, 01:47:12 PM
Interesting will take a deeper look

this baby has rock solid forward live results.

a few accounts only stopped due to brokers going out of business or server changes like pepper.

i looked into this deeply, and its the cats meow of a scalper.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Ruairi OPleurisy on February 24, 2017, 02:01:35 PM
On Donna's reference account it shows two trades being taken at exactly the same time in the same direction, with one closing in profit and the other closing for a loss.  The losing trade was closed early, whilst the winner was allowed to run on for longer.  Strange :-

(https://donnaforex.com/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fthumbsnap.com%2Fi%2FXCV6rkjN.png&hash=9468311def89b0b51a0669b2131ee0a9)

Donna, that account hasn't updated since Tue 21st so maybe need to check it is ok.  Possibly just MyFxBook.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on February 24, 2017, 03:20:50 PM
I have fixed it, it was myfxbook - the account is running normally :). Results are looking good so far. https://www.myfxbook.com/members/donnaforexreal/forexrealprofitea/1986442
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: candlesurfer on February 27, 2017, 12:17:29 PM
Thanks Donna, really appreciated

I have been considering this for a while and the discount you have kindly negotiated may well tip the balance... do you know if the discount will apply every year or just as a one off?

Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on February 27, 2017, 12:22:20 PM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Byte on February 27, 2017, 08:24:11 PM
Just a quick note: I have been using the EA for two years or so and am overall very happy with it. The one thing to be aware of - really no reason not to use the EA but important for managing your VPS resources - the EA has phases with relatively high CPU utilisation. So you should make sure your VPS is up for it.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: candlesurfer on February 27, 2017, 09:05:33 PM
Just a quick note: I have been using the EA for two years or so and am overall very happy with it. The one thing to be aware of - really no reason not to use the EA but important for managing your VPS resources - the EA has phases with relatively high CPU utilisation. So you should make sure your VPS is up for it.

Thanks for the warning. Would you be able to share what annual performance you achieved?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: reinerh on February 27, 2017, 09:17:52 PM
Just a quick note: I have been using the EA for two years or so and am overall very happy with it. The one thing to be aware of - really no reason not to use the EA but important for managing your VPS resources - the EA has phases with relatively high CPU utilisation. So you should make sure your VPS is up for it.

byte,

does it use mqlock for protection ??

Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Byte on February 27, 2017, 10:25:56 PM
@candlesurfer
Just a quick note: I have been using the EA for two years or so and am overall very happy with it. The one thing to be aware of - really no reason not to use the EA but important for managing your VPS resources - the EA has phases with relatively high CPU utilisation. So you should make sure your VPS is up for it.

Thanks for the warning. Would you be able to share what annual performance you achieved?
For consistency: I have been running ForexRealProfitEA since August 2015 on a GlobalPrime account (had it on other brokers before, but that gets things mixed up). It is running with a bunch of other EAs, so it is messy to share, but here is what I have:
Total performance up until today is +31.7% (with a very painful first half of the time) at max DD of 12.6%
I attached the monthly performance (I hope the upload works, otherwise I will type it in).
Performance would have been better, if I had always turned off some strategies as they occasionally advise via email, but often I was a bit late with it and besides it is just very annoying to change 4 settings in x number of pairs but clearly worth it for the money. I try to get better discipline on that.
@reinerh
Just a quick note: I have been using the EA for two years or so and am overall very happy with it. The one thing to be aware of - really no reason not to use the EA but important for managing your VPS resources - the EA has phases with relatively high CPU utilisation. So you should make sure your VPS is up for it.

byte,

does it use mqlock for protection ??


I think they are not using mqlock but some kind of encrypted DLL and decryption seems to take significant resources.


Just a side note: service is great. I was frustrated with performance in between and checked with them if that was in line with what they see, and they did a detailed review for me. Unfortunately, there was nothing wrong with my setup but this way I knew and it started performing later again.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Surrealistik on February 28, 2017, 10:36:20 AM
Been running this EA for close to 3 years at this point, and it has been consistently profitable, averaging somewhere around 5% / MO with peak to trough DDs in the low to mid 20%s (I do use higher risk settings; roughly +50% risk on average, + money management, however) over this entire time on a CNS VPS at IC Markets.

Adrian and FRPEA support in general have always been top notch, usually replying within a day or two, and always have been very helpful, friendly and informative.

Solid EA with a strategy that the dev team continually reviews, tweaks and refine, while systemically and methodically reviewing the impact of modifications to the strategy via backtesting (I believe backtesting is based upon data going back more than 12 years, and tick data going back more than 8 ) and forward testing, which helps assure the robustness of the system. In general, after years of continual, consistent profitability, I've come to trust it with increasing amounts of capital (I recommend everyone do the same for any system no matter how promising; scale up the investment as it builds gains; don't jump in all at once) which have accumulated to a significant level.

In balance, can't recommend it enough. I do feel though that you need to find the right broker and a good VPS in order to truly realize its potential and returns. As above, I've used IC Markets and CNS with success. Excel Markets (when it existed) and Global Prime have also proven excellent venues for trading the EA.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: candlesurfer on February 28, 2017, 11:09:57 AM
@candlesurfer
Just a quick note: I have been using the EA for two years or so and am overall very happy with it. The one thing to be aware of - really no reason not to use the EA but important for managing your VPS resources - the EA has phases with relatively high CPU utilisation. So you should make sure your VPS is up for it.

Thanks for the warning. Would you be able to share what annual performance you achieved?
For consistency: I have been running ForexRealProfitEA since August 2015 on a GlobalPrime account (had it on other brokers before, but that gets things mixed up). It is running with a bunch of other EAs, so it is messy to share, but here is what I have:
Total performance up until today is +31.7% (with a very painful first half of the time) at max DD of 12.6%
I attached the monthly performance (I hope the upload works, otherwise I will type it in).
Performance would have been better, if I had always turned off some strategies as they occasionally advise via email, but often I was a bit late with it and besides it is just very annoying to change 4 settings in x number of pairs but clearly worth it for the money. I try to get better discipline on that.
@reinerh
Just a quick note: I have been using the EA for two years or so and am overall very happy with it. The one thing to be aware of - really no reason not to use the EA but important for managing your VPS resources - the EA has phases with relatively high CPU utilisation. So you should make sure your VPS is up for it.

byte,

does it use mqlock for protection ??


I think they are not using mqlock but some kind of encrypted DLL and decryption seems to take significant resources.


Just a side note: service is great. I was frustrated with performance in between and checked with them if that was in line with what they see, and they did a detailed review for me. Unfortunately, there was nothing wrong with my setup but this way I knew and it started performing later again.


Byte, thank you so much for sharing. By the sounds of it if using the EA one has to tweak as advised by the vendor to get the best results. That doesn't sounds too bad a price to pay for ensuring good performance. The yearly pricing model makes me confident they will stay on top of things as if nobody renews due to poor performance they don't get paid...
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: bleach on February 28, 2017, 11:49:57 PM
Can the vendor remove vat charges for international customers?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on March 01, 2017, 08:24:13 AM
You can change the VAT amount applied to the purchase by changing the "country" in the dropdown box on the bottom of the signup page... it'll auto-refresh with the VAT removed.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: bleach on March 02, 2017, 02:13:29 PM
Thanks Donna!
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on March 26, 2017, 06:19:12 PM
Looking at the "Live" myfxbook performance of this EA, I have the following concerns:

1- The monthly return to drawdown, is reasonable but nothing exemplary. Daily: 0.11% Monthly: 3.47%, Drawdown: 27.30%.

2- The myfxbook posting is "curious" in that even the latest one as well as all previous records, "ForexRealProfitEA_ICMarkets Real (USD), IC Markets, Technical, Automated, 1:100, MetaTrader 4", Track Record Not Verified.

3- Why are all previous to Real Account Statement 2,3,4, DukasCopy are posted when they are irrelevant since they were stopped a long time ago?

Regards,

Ilios Ellas
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on March 28, 2017, 04:56:05 PM
Dear iliosellas,

The monthly profit depends on the risk settings, we set an average low risk, for long term performance with a lower draw down.
The average yearly profit is 40% for the last 7 years.

Track record was verified, but on every MT4 platform update, Myfxbook changed the robot that published our track record and we had to update their robot for this reason every time for the last 7 years. Now we have to make a new statement link and delete the old one, in order to work.

Please check FXBlue statement, the confirmation is there.

The oldest MBTrading account was verified by Donna also at the time.
More details on the old Donna forum link also.

Regarding the old statements, we keep the rest of the discontinued statements for the sake of continuity, to keep track of all 7 years of live trading history.
 
For example, Real Account Statement 2 and Real Account Statement 3 show the trading results of our older versions of the robot, v5 and v6.
Our old Pepperstone Razor accounts were not supported by the broker due to some major changes and were closed by the broker.
 Real Account Statement 4 is our oldest account, when all started on April 2010 and was closed by the broker; MBTrading closed its forex business.

Kind regards,
Adrian
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on March 31, 2017, 02:42:13 PM
Hello, i have Buy now FRPE now, my Brokers are ForexTime and XM ECN, somebody know there okay for this EA?.

I wait now for the Mail with the Passwort..

regards
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: IFFTrader on April 01, 2017, 01:25:49 AM
Try to find brokers with tight spread such as ECN broker. If you are referring to XM cents account I won't run it there
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 02, 2017, 12:49:01 PM
Hi,

Tight spreads (ECN) and good price feed (many partner banks) can improve the long term performance for any trading strategy.

Forex brokers spread comparison useful link:
http://www.myfxbook.com/forex-broker-spreads
and add "Include Commissions" option.

Better use it during the week, when the forex market is open and check few days in a row for better results.

Kind regards,
Adrian
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 03, 2017, 12:12:37 AM
Okay, Thank you, I test
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 03, 2017, 01:49:24 PM
Hello, i get this error: ForexRealProfitEAv6.55 EURAUD,M15: Add the address 'http://www.forexrealprofitea.com' in the list of allowed URLs on tab 'Expert Advisors'Error64

Is already in the list

regards

Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 03, 2017, 08:46:54 PM
Dear Wrockert,

It's important to add the address "http://www.forexrealprofitea.com" in the list of allowed URLs on MT4 / Tools / Options / 'Expert Advisors' tab and check "Allow WebRequest for listed URL:" box also.

Some error messages might appear occasionally, due to writing new file error or connection issues, but this doesn't affect the overall performance, as long as the settings are correct and the error messages appears occasionally.

The robot uses the last known values until the next update.

Useful link: https://www.myfxbook.com/community/outlook can be used to check if everything works correctly by comparing the "MarketBuySentiment" chart values with Myfxbook (buy sentiment) values. All updates are on every 5 minutes from our website.

Kind regards,
Adrian
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 04, 2017, 12:24:53 AM
Dear Wrockert,

It's important to add the address "http://www.forexrealprofitea.com" in the list of allowed URLs on MT4 / Tools / Options / 'Expert Advisors' tab and check "Allow WebRequest for listed URL:" box also.

Some error messages might appear occasionally, due to writing new file error or connection issues, but this doesn't affect the overall performance, as long as the settings are correct and the error messages appears occasionally.

The robot uses the last known values until the next update.

Useful link: https://www.myfxbook.com/community/outlook can be used to check if everything works correctly by comparing the "MarketBuySentiment" chart values with Myfxbook (buy sentiment) values. All updates are on every 5 minutes from our website.

Kind regards,
Adrian
ForexRealProfitEA Team.

ok, thank you, maybee because of connections.

what i see now, the EA show GMT 02:23 , but GMT is: 23:24

regards


Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 20, 2017, 11:18:17 PM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)

One has got to be trading piles of cash to afford paying them $179 every year for this bot and stay net profitable with it thereafter.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 21, 2017, 05:48:00 AM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)

One has got to be trading piles of cash to afford paying them $179 every year for this bot and stay net profitable with it thereafter.

If the EA is any Year profitabele, then its a very Cheap invest, i buy a lot of EAs , cheap and Expensive, but all fail. This EA has a long nice History and is robust. I run it now on Demo together with a Controller EA, any Strategy is Controlled
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 21, 2017, 09:46:46 AM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)

One has got to be trading piles of cash to afford paying them $179 every year for this bot and stay net profitable with it thereafter.

If the EA is any Year profitabele, then its a very Cheap invest, i buy a lot of EAs , cheap and Expensive, but all fail. This EA has a long nice History and is robust. I run it now on Demo together with a Controller EA, any Strategy is Controlled

I hope wealth comes your way before a margin call.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 21, 2017, 11:50:26 AM
Dear pipsbuster,

That is a free statement based on nothing and can apply to any robot, business or life plan as well.

For example, our recommended risk is 25% from the maximum draw down for the last 14 years of tickdata backtest.

Based on Monte Carlo analysis, the largest loss could be double.

Our money management works like this:

1000:1.25=8000,
8000:1.25=6400,

So, using the money management system, even if you lose 2 times more, you still got 64% of the account.

The difference is almost the yearly profit, for the last 7 years of live treading on real accounts by the way.

Regarding the pile of cash to use our robot, a $450 account should pay the yearly subscription, anything above is net profit.

Regarding the subscription, we took this decision to use the resources and time we have available to continually improve our performance, to bring the best quality to our products and the best support for our members on long term.

My advice for traders: just plan your trades and trade your plan; everybody can win on forex if it's a good plan, tested on long term and used with a smart risk.

Best regards,
Adrian
FRPEA team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on April 21, 2017, 01:28:39 PM
Dear pipsbuster,

That is a free statement based on nothing and can apply to any robot, business or life plan as well.

For example, our recommended risk is 25% from the maximum draw down for the last 14 years of tickdata backtest.

Based on Monte Carlo analysis, the largest loss could be double.

Our money management works like this:

1000:1.25=8000,
8000:1.25=6400,

So, using the money management system, even if you lose 2 times more, you still got 64% of the account.

The difference is almost the yearly profit, for the last 7 years of live treading on real accounts by the way.

Regarding the pile of cash to use our robot, a $450 account should pay the yearly subscription, anything above is net profit.

Regarding the subscription, we took this decision to use the resources and time we have available to continually improve our performance, to bring the best quality to our products and the best support for our members on long term.

My advice for traders: just plan your trades and trade your plan; everybody can win on forex if it's a good plan, tested on long term and used with a smart risk.

Best regards,
Adrian
FRPEA team.


I am demo testing Forex Real Profit EA at the moment. Although is is too early, from what I see, this seems to be a stable and sure footed EA: It works slowly and deliberately. The support service has been excellent.

I will report back once I have demo tested this a reasonable amount of time.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas




Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: IFFTrader on April 21, 2017, 02:45:39 PM
I run this ea on live account but with few months experience. This EA is good for me. Time will tell.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 21, 2017, 04:33:09 PM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)

One has got to be trading piles of cash to afford paying them $179 every year for this bot and stay net profitable with it thereafter.

If the EA is any Year profitabele, then its a very Cheap invest, i buy a lot of EAs , cheap and Expensive, but all fail. This EA has a long nice History and is robust. I run it now on Demo together with a Controller EA, any Strategy is Controlled

I hope wealth comes your way before a margin call.

Before you judge , Analyse and Test the EA, i build a bigger System with more EAs for different Market situations. I run Test now.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: canis on April 21, 2017, 04:41:14 PM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)

One has got to be trading piles of cash to afford paying them $179 every year for this bot and stay net profitable with it thereafter.

At $ 99 a year, the number of subscribers would increase by an order of magnitude
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 21, 2017, 05:07:20 PM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)

One has got to be trading piles of cash to afford paying them $179 every year for this bot and stay net profitable with it thereafter.

At $ 99 a year, the number of subscribers would increase by an order of magnitude

Yes, but you see the Price from CABEX? 540/ Year, crazy
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on April 21, 2017, 09:38:05 PM
i believe it's every year.. if you click the 10% off link  (http://donnaforex.forexrealprofiteafor5.click2sell.eu/?checkout)it says "$216.59 every 1 year" (they do add 21% VAT which is the only downside but no avoiding that in this case)

One has got to be trading piles of cash to afford paying them $179 every year for this bot and stay net profitable with it thereafter.

At $ 99 a year, the number of subscribers would increase by an order of magnitude

Yes, but you see the Price from CABEX? 540/ Year, crazy


Let's do an analysis:

FOREXREALPROFIT:

ForexRealProfitEA_10%discount Product Type Subscription Terms 179.0 USD every 1 year:
 Seller UAB Click2Sell Total Amount $ 179.00

It has been running on “forexgermany” since Jan. 2014 or app. 28 months. The account is Track Record Verified, Trading Privileges Verified with a Monthly return of 4.45% and a Drawdown: 21.19% .

http://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexgermany/forex-real-profit-ea/803413

CABEX:

Product/Service name Delivery Quantity Unit price Value CabEX EA Annual Subscription - V3.6 Electronic $540.00. The billing currency is USD ($) Total price: $540.00

It has been running on “forexgermany” since Jan. 2015 or app. 15 months. The account is  Track  Record Verified, Trading Privileges Verified with a Monthly return of  3.51% and a Drawdown: 12.62%.

http://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexgermany/cabex/1134749

With all being equal, which they are not “slightly”, the difference in the yearly subscription price is 540$ - 179$ = 361$. ForexRealProfit (a) Has been runing and live tested  by a third party, a year longer than CabEx. (b) Althought it has a slightly higher DD, it returns a 1% higher monthy gain, which if compounded on a yearly basis, could give you a sizable added return in addition to the 361$, yearly savings.


Regards,
Ilios Ellas.

Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 22, 2017, 10:37:29 AM
In reality, vendors and affiliates watch their live tests like hawks - something their clients often don't have time and ability to do.

Also, don't forget to factor in the VPS costs.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 22, 2017, 11:48:04 AM
In reality, vendors and affiliates watch their live tests like hawks - something their clients often don't have time and ability to do.

Also, don't forget to factor in the VPS costs.

Donna has also a FRPE Account , looks not Bad. Which EA you use??
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 22, 2017, 12:18:09 PM
In reality, vendors and affiliates watch their live tests like hawks - something their clients often don't have time and ability to do.

Also, don't forget to factor in the VPS costs.

Donna has also a FRPE Account , looks not Bad. Which EA you use??

I use several custom-built ones. I'm also experimenting with a few commercial EAs but it's too early to tell. Members of the World Wide Invest forum noticed some time ago that Forex Real Profit EA has some dates filtered out in its code to hide losses on backtests.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 22, 2017, 02:03:53 PM
In reality, vendors and affiliates watch their live tests like hawks - something their clients often don't have time and ability to do.

Also, don't forget to factor in the VPS costs.

Donna has also a FRPE Account , looks not Bad. Which EA you use??

I use several custom-built ones. I'm also experimenting with a few commercial EAs but it's too early to tell. Members of the World Wide Invest forum noticed some time ago that Forex Real Profit EA has some dates filtered out in its code to hide losses on backtests.

Hmm, its an old and anywhere known Dirty trick, time will tell us the True
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 22, 2017, 06:57:11 PM
Dear pipsbuster,

That's not true.

We code future dates into the program, to avoid scalping strategies to run during USA bank holidays.

And we add those dates on every update, on yearly basis.

I had those conversations 7 years ago when we started, I thought we passed this point.

Also, this information is written on every FRPEA manual, for the last 7 years.

I see you are here to disqualify our work, based on lying and deception only.

The price of VPS is not our fault though.

Next time I'll check your robot, the one you promote.

Regards,
Adrian
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on April 22, 2017, 07:10:54 PM
In reality, vendors and affiliates watch their live tests like hawks - something their clients often don't have time and ability to do.

Also, don't forget to factor in the VPS costs.

Pipbuster, I am not sure what you are referring to with this comment? Anyone who is serious about forex trading and using EA's, is not doing justice to his investment or to the EA he is using, especially any EA which is worth its value by not using a VPS: VPS's have come down in price and are exceedingly cheap.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 22, 2017, 07:27:57 PM
In reality, vendors and affiliates watch their live tests like hawks - something their clients often don't have time and ability to do.

Also, don't forget to factor in the VPS costs.

Pipbuster, I am not sure what you are referring to with this comment? Anyone who is serious about forex trading and using EA's, is not doing justice to his investment or to the EA he is using, especially any EA which is worth its value by not using a VPS: VPS's have come down in price and are exceedingly cheap.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas
Profits from this type of EAs are equally low, so they might not even cover the annual license costs + the VPS expenses unless you trade a larger amount and get lucky not to hit several losses in a row for long enough.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on April 22, 2017, 07:54:58 PM
In reality, vendors and affiliates watch their live tests like hawks - something their clients often don't have time and ability to do.

Also, don't forget to factor in the VPS costs.

I log into my VPS twice (sometimes three times) a day to check that there are no problems and everything is running smoothly. There's nothing to be gained by watching them beyond making sure the VPS is up and running - i certainly don't interfere with EA trades as it wouldn't be a fair test, and i'd probably make it trade much worse anyway  ;D ;D. I'd recommend anyone trading live money to check their VPS at least once a day.

One thing i notice that testers / sellers often do differently though is to run a test over a longer period of time. When you purchase a product for yourself you don't have this luxury if you have a product that you can refund and it is close to refund date expiry.

Combine this with the fact that most people pile into products when they have had an amazing run, and it's no surprise that some folk end up riding the downward wave on EA after EA after EA.

Better strategy as someone buying a product is to do very thorough research and understand the ins and outs of a product before jumping in and then when you do go in to it, to commit to it for at least 6 months of trading. For this reason it's good to see yearly subscriptions rather than monthly as it encourages better trading habits. Now i know this looks biased coming from me as an affiliate probably trying to persuade you to buy something so i can pay our server bills, but it is the truth as i see it. Ultimately, i do better business if i can keep traders sticking around long term, not buying and refunding on an endless cycle- seeing people go through account after account in this way actually makes me frustrated and sad. If this post saves one person from jumping into something too soon, then i'll be happy.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 22, 2017, 08:01:48 PM
One way to avoid falling for the filtered dates on a backtest is to find an old version of the bot and backtest it over the subsequent years. There's an old version 5.11 of this EA on the web back from the year of 2011. If one backtests it over the subsequent years of 2012-2013, they will see it loses big time.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 22, 2017, 08:30:40 PM
So pipsbuster,

Great, another lie.
Now we are talking about some pirated version of a robot named after our first release.

Here are all the updates by the way:
http://www.forexrealprofitea.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=3

The name you mentioned worked 2 months until our next version.

And we keep track of all trades on real accounts since we started, April 10, 2010.
What is so hard to understand?

Adrian,
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 22, 2017, 08:44:32 PM
So pipsbuster,

Great, another lie.
Now we are talking about some pirated version of a robot named after our first release.

Here are all the updates by the way:
http://www.forexrealprofitea.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=3

The robot you mentioned worked 2 months until our next version.

And we keep track of all trades on real accounts since we started, April 10, 2010.
What is so hard to understand?

Adrian,
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Oh really? Is this also a lie?

https://forum.worldwide-invest.org/trading-expert-advisors-ea/2474-forex-real-profit-ea-post244049.html#post244049
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 22, 2017, 08:50:40 PM
Yes pipsbuster,

Another lie.

Check USA bank holidays at this link:
http://www.officeholidays.com/countries/usa/2012.php

All dates are bank holidays, written for the future use.

All holiday dates are written for 2 days, one for the brokers with positive GMT offset and one for negative offset.

Adrian,
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 22, 2017, 08:54:05 PM
Yes pipsbuster,

Another lie.

Check USA bank holidays at this link:
http://www.officeholidays.com/countries/usa/2012.php

All dates are bank holidays, written for the future use.

All holiday dates are written for 2 days, one for the brokers with positive GMT offset and one for negative offset.

Adrian,
ForexRealProfitEA Team.

All right then - I'm not here to argue with you. May I, please, get your original version's ex4 for my perusal? I'll pay you if I have to.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 22, 2017, 09:17:28 PM
Nice read.

Bring back old memories.

Please send us an email, in case of affiliate request.

Adrian
FRPEA
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 22, 2017, 09:19:42 PM
Nice read.

Bring back old memories.

Please send us an email, in case of affiliate request.

Adrian
FRPEA
PMed you with my email address.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on April 22, 2017, 10:36:35 PM
Nice read.

Bring back old memories.

Please send us an email, in case of affiliate request.

Adrian
FRPEA
PMed you with my email address.

I don't see what all this chatter and back and forth is leading to or can be gained by it.

Donna is running this EA live and we can see the results day by day. This is much more transparent than some other sites who weekly declare, "And the winner is....", posting results of EA's they are running without myfxbook posts or analysis and sending you e-mail to purchase this that and the other EA to which they are affiliates. Because of this trust of Donna's live tests, and myfxbook analysis, I have become involved both with the ForexRealProfit EA and the Best Scalper. Thus far, from my demo tests, my results parallel that of Donna's live trades. True, Donna is an affiliate and has a financial interest in this but I don't, "I am not an affiliate of any vendor, nor do I wish to become one.": Having a good and reliable EA is sufficient reward for me.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: ianj on April 23, 2017, 12:32:46 AM
Hmm, its an old and anywhere known Dirty trick, time will tell us the True

Hmm!

Am not sure i agree - at least in simplistic terms.

If trading ranges (times/dates etc) have been excluded then it is not necessarily an intention to deceive. There are legitimate reasons to exclude some, but i do think these should be publicized by the vendor, even at the expense of betraying some "trade secrets"

It is perfectly legitimate to identify that the ea generally performs poorly at a specific time as the EA regime changes. One example is a break out or reversal strategy - the times and weekdays the strategy is active is CRUCIAL to the operating performance of the strategy (In this respect trading at 22:55, 23:00, 23:05 can be very very different, and Monday and Thursday can hardly be compared)

I do, however, agree that surgically removing specific dates in order to take out individual large losses is nefarious. The technique is mostly detectable (Birt often did it) by sliding/changing data but as with other cases it is generally not obvious without specific tooling
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 10:24:27 AM
Nice read.

Bring back old memories.

Please send us an email, in case of affiliate request.

Adrian
FRPEA
PMed you with my email address.

I don't see what all this chatter and back and forth is leading to or can be gained by it.

Donna is running this EA live and we can see the results day by day. This is much more transparent than some other sites who weekly declare, "And the winner is....", posting results of EA's they are running without myfxbook posts or analysis and sending you e-mail to purchase this that and the other EA to which they are affiliates. Because of this trust of Donna's live tests, and myfxbook analysis, I have become involved both with the ForexRealProfit EA and the Best Scalper. Thus far, from my demo tests, my results parallel that of Donna's live trades. True, Donna is an affiliate and has a financial interest in this but I don't, "I am not an affiliate of any vendor, nor do I wish to become one.": Having a good and reliable EA is sufficient reward for me.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas

This EA has been actively marketed since 2010. Based on the profits it claims, it must have produced lots of wealthy users by now. Yet no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't find any online. Are you one?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 23, 2017, 01:12:28 PM
Nice read.

Bring back old memories.

Please send us an email, in case of affiliate request.

Adrian
FRPEA
PMed you with my email address.

I don't see what all this chatter and back and forth is leading to or can be gained by it.

Donna is running this EA live and we can see the results day by day. This is much more transparent than some other sites who weekly declare, "And the winner is....", posting results of EA's they are running without myfxbook posts or analysis and sending you e-mail to purchase this that and the other EA to which they are affiliates. Because of this trust of Donna's live tests, and myfxbook analysis, I have become involved both with the ForexRealProfit EA and the Best Scalper. Thus far, from my demo tests, my results parallel that of Donna's live trades. True, Donna is an affiliate and has a financial interest in this but I don't, "I am not an affiliate of any vendor, nor do I wish to become one.": Having a good and reliable EA is sufficient reward for me.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas

This EA has been actively marketed since 2010. Based on the profits it claims, it must have produced lots of wealthy users by now. Yet no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't find any online. Are you one?

On myfxbook http://www.myfxbook.com/members/fxwatanabe3/forexrealprofitea/1771579
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 01:18:26 PM
Nice read.

Bring back old memories.

Please send us an email, in case of affiliate request.

Adrian
FRPEA
PMed you with my email address.

I don't see what all this chatter and back and forth is leading to or can be gained by it.

Donna is running this EA live and we can see the results day by day. This is much more transparent than some other sites who weekly declare, "And the winner is....", posting results of EA's they are running without myfxbook posts or analysis and sending you e-mail to purchase this that and the other EA to which they are affiliates. Because of this trust of Donna's live tests, and myfxbook analysis, I have become involved both with the ForexRealProfit EA and the Best Scalper. Thus far, from my demo tests, my results parallel that of Donna's live trades. True, Donna is an affiliate and has a financial interest in this but I don't, "I am not an affiliate of any vendor, nor do I wish to become one.": Having a good and reliable EA is sufficient reward for me.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas

This EA has been actively marketed since 2010. Based on the profits it claims, it must have produced lots of wealthy users by now. Yet no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't find any online. Are you one?

On myfxbook http://www.myfxbook.com/members/fxwatanabe3/forexrealprofitea/1771579
48% on a cent account after a year hardly qualifies for the definition of wealth.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on April 23, 2017, 01:36:33 PM
Nice read.

Bring back old memories.

Please send us an email, in case of affiliate request.

Adrian
FRPEA
PMed you with my email address.

I don't see what all this chatter and back and forth is leading to or can be gained by it.

Donna is running this EA live and we can see the results day by day. This is much more transparent than some other sites who weekly declare, "And the winner is....", posting results of EA's they are running without myfxbook posts or analysis and sending you e-mail to purchase this that and the other EA to which they are affiliates. Because of this trust of Donna's live tests, and myfxbook analysis, I have become involved both with the ForexRealProfit EA and the Best Scalper. Thus far, from my demo tests, my results parallel that of Donna's live trades. True, Donna is an affiliate and has a financial interest in this but I don't, "I am not an affiliate of any vendor, nor do I wish to become one.": Having a good and reliable EA is sufficient reward for me.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas

This EA has been actively marketed since 2010. Based on the profits it claims, it must have produced lots of wealthy users by now. Yet no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't find any online. Are you one?

On myfxbook http://www.myfxbook.com/members/fxwatanabe3/forexrealprofitea/1771579
48% on a cent account after a year hardly qualifies for the definition of wealth.

The % and the Trades are Important,  I know, 48% is not enought for you, but look at the big Hedgefonds, there more then happy with this.... 
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 01:43:27 PM
The % and the Trades are Important,  I know, 48% is not enought for you, but look at the big Hedgefonds, there more then happy with this....

I'm not running a hedge fund. The account type is equally important - cent accounts don't have any execution issues or abrupt spread spikes.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: reinerh on April 23, 2017, 02:14:42 PM
The % and the Trades are Important,  I know, 48% is not enought for you, but look at the big Hedgefonds, there more then happy with this....

I'm not running a hedge fund. The account type is equally important - cent accounts don't have any execution issues or abrupt spread spikes.

but cent account have huge spreads, that sucks up a lot of profits.

also all their official accounts were decent.

i dont run their ea but its a decent ea none or less.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 02:23:11 PM
The % and the Trades are Important,  I know, 48% is not enought for you, but look at the big Hedgefonds, there more then happy with this....

I'm not running a hedge fund. The account type is equally important - cent accounts don't have any execution issues or abrupt spread spikes.

but cent account have huge spreads, that sucks up a lot of profits.

also all their official accounts were decent.

i dont run their ea but its a decent ea none or less.

I always take any proof coming directly from the vendor with a decent grain of salt. That's why I'm asking for third-party proof which should be massive after a whole of seven years on the market.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: dutchie on April 23, 2017, 02:32:21 PM
The % and the Trades are Important,  I know, 48% is not enought for you, but look at the big Hedgefonds, there more then happy with this....

I'm not running a hedge fund. The account type is equally important - cent accounts don't have any execution issues or abrupt spread spikes.

but cent account have huge spreads, that sucks up a lot of profits.

also all their official accounts were decent.

i dont run their ea but its a decent ea none or less.

I always take any proof coming directly from the vendor with a decent grain of salt. That's why I'm asking for third-party proof which should be massive after a whole of seven years on the market.
Guess all those millionaires are enjoining their money in silence (don't wake up tax people who surf the net for victims)
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 02:49:16 PM
The % and the Trades are Important,  I know, 48% is not enought for you, but look at the big Hedgefonds, there more then happy with this....

I'm not running a hedge fund. The account type is equally important - cent accounts don't have any execution issues or abrupt spread spikes.

but cent account have huge spreads, that sucks up a lot of profits.

also all their official accounts were decent.

i dont run their ea but its a decent ea none or less.

I always take any proof coming directly from the vendor with a decent grain of salt. That's why I'm asking for third-party proof which should be massive after a whole of seven years on the market.
Guess all those millionaires are enjoining their money in silence (don't wake up tax people who surf the net for victims)

MyFXBook doesn't require any personal information from its users.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on April 23, 2017, 03:08:08 PM
The % and the Trades are Important,  I know, 48% is not enought for you, but look at the big Hedgefonds, there more then happy with this....

I'm not running a hedge fund. The account type is equally important - cent accounts don't have any execution issues or abrupt spread spikes.

but cent account have huge spreads, that sucks up a lot of profits.

also all their official accounts were decent.

i dont run their ea but its a decent ea none or less.

I always take any proof coming directly from the vendor with a decent grain of salt. That's why I'm asking for third-party proof which should be massive after a whole of seven years on the market.
Guess all those millionaires are enjoining their money in silence (don't wake up tax people who surf the net for victims)

MyFXBook doesn't require any personal information from its users.

This thread is sucking a lot of hot air.

Donna has a live account running, I am running the EA as well and I am sure additional members who are just staying out of this "chatter". Let's come back to this 6 months from now and compare. Pipbuster, put this on your calendar and come back then.

Regards,
Ilios Ellas
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 03:45:56 PM
Below is the tick data backtest of the initial release v5.11 on the recommended EURUSD pair. The EA file is dated 15.02.2011. Therefore, its backtesting over the subsequent period can be regarded as walk-forward analysis.

The steady account balance growth on the backtest predates the release date. Yet the account takes a rather heavy slump in the vicinity of 25% of the account with the recommended default settings right after the start of the post-release period and stays stagnant from then on for years, all the way until now.

Now factor in the annual license costs and the VPS costs to understand why you would not be net profitable over these seven years. Yet if you look at only the last couple of months of trading, the EA will appear as if it's profitable.  ;D

No wonder the vendor felt compelled to keep adding extra strategies in his multiple updates. Some of them, based on Donna's live test, don't even set SL for their trades. Any market flash crash, like the one on GBPUSD on October 7 last year, would wipe out your account in no time, provided you were in the market with trades that had no stop-losses the moment it happened.

Yet I'm more than willing to give people (even vendors who are after our cash) the benefit of doubt. That's why I PMed this Adrian guy with my email address for a genuine ex4 file of the initial release to backtest it against this one which he regards as a useless crack. I haven't heard back from him since yesterday.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 23, 2017, 06:00:31 PM
Dear pipsbuster,

Ok, here we go again.

First of all, I'm sure that your version of FRPEA 5.11 is not the official release.

Another detail, we offered free demo version of our robots for 2 years (2011-2013) and free support also.

In addition, the robot is running on verified real accounts since the beginning.

Here are all the updates, (in exchange for the subscription fee):
http://www.forexrealprofitea.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=3

As I said before, according to our real account results, a $450 account should pay the yearly subscription, anything above is net profit.

The Stop Loss defines the maximum value in pips when the robot will close a losing position.
Our robots use a dynamic Stop Loss algorithm and most of the trades are closed at a lower loss than the maximum Stop Loss permitted.
Same story for the Take Profit.
The maximum stop loss is 150 pips, but it differs depending on the currency or strategy used, from 50 to 150.
The breakout strategy has a SL, but it's hidden; it works only at the close of the candle.

The average results from our official account and 5972 trades:
Average Win: +11.10 pips
Average Loss: -16.85 pips

In our case, professional trading logic (improved over 5 years of live trading experience), volatility filters, trading hours and average trade length helped to avoid the market storms and keeped the profit safe.

Here is another third party account statement link:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexgermany/forex-real-profit-ea/803413

Please check the email.
Complete backtest reports are available for our members.

Regards,
Adrian
ForexRealProfitEA Team.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 06:24:40 PM
Yes, I have seen the live test of your affiliate and that of yours. Can you post some links to the long-term live tests of your clients though? I would imagine there would be hundreds of them over the seven years this EA has been on the market.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: reinerh on April 23, 2017, 06:27:52 PM
Yes, I have seen the live test of your affiliate and that of yours. Can you post some links to the long-term live tests of your clients though? I would imagine there would be hundreds of them over the seven years this EA has been on the market.

how in the heck can a vendor post a customer account, gimme a break.

i am all for myfxbook, but trust me on this one good/fat ones dont get posted publicly for many many reasons.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 06:30:44 PM
Yes, I have seen the live test of your affiliate and that of yours. Can you post some links to the long-term live tests of your clients though? I would imagine there would be hundreds of them over the seven years this EA has been on the market.

how in the heck can a vendor post a customer account, gimme a break.

i am all for myfxbook, but trust me on this one good/fat ones dont get posted publicly for many many reasons.

I would then happily settle for as little as the ex4 file of the initial release for my testing to prove my findings wrong. Adrian, can you provide it to me?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 23, 2017, 06:34:12 PM
Yes, I have seen the live test of your affiliate and that of yours. Can you post some links to the long-term live tests of your clients though? I would imagine there would be hundreds of them over the seven years this EA has been on the market.

No, I don't post our clients results.
Yes, some clients since the beginning.

The initial release no longer works, after the MT4 build updates.
We don't have any updates to our expired versions of the robot that works on the latest MT4 platform.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: pipsbuster on April 23, 2017, 06:37:22 PM
Yes, I have seen the live test of your affiliate and that of yours. Can you post some links to the long-term live tests of your clients though? I would imagine there would be hundreds of them over the seven years this EA has been on the market.

No, I don't post our clients results.
Yes, some clients since the beginning.

The initial release no longer works, after the MT4 build updates.
We donít have any updates to our expired versions.

Just what I thought.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on April 23, 2017, 08:58:44 PM
Yes, I have seen the live test of your affiliate and that of yours. Can you post some links to the long-term live tests of your clients though? I would imagine there would be hundreds of them over the seven years this EA has been on the market.

No, I don't post our clients results.
Yes, some clients since the beginning.

The initial release no longer works, after the MT4 build updates.
We donít have any updates to our expired versions.

Just what I thought.

Pipbuster, what does, "Just what I thought." mean?

Stop, hitting and running. Your challenge has been accepted, let's wait until Oct. 2017 or thereabouts and we will revisit your claims.


Regards,
Ilios Ellas
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: eaonly on April 23, 2017, 09:38:34 PM
We don't have updates to our expired versions of the robot that works on MT4 build 600+.

Everything changed since March 2014 and working in MT4 64-bit systems forced us to rewrite the trading algorithm all over again.

Testing the old versions of the robot on new MT4 600+ platform will perform randomly; most of the array values (like bid and ask price) are no longer recognized.

Adrian
FRPEA
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: ichfunktion on April 24, 2017, 10:44:14 AM
@pipsbuster
Your approach is not consistent! You BT an old version from 2011 and reclaim that this is can be used a forward test. Assuming this EA will work with MT4 build 600+ (and this assumption is not true based on the previous post by the vendor), you can only do this if the EA has not changed. But the vendor provided new versions (which are maybe improved and optimized) and shown with this that he supported the customer over the last years and that the yearly subscription is worth the money.
Another argument from your side is that the vendor take out trading dates in newer versions to improve BT results (worse results from the past). The vendor explained the strategy to take out specific dates for future trading (and this makes sense). Therefore it comes down to trusting the vendor or some independent results. For myself I trust forexgermany and see no indication how this long term results can be manipulated here.

If you have no further indications of manipulations, I think is enough then.

For myself I'm not using this EA yet. Although I like lately EA with a yearly subscription (as a kind of commitment to support the EA also in the future) it was a little bit to expensive for me in the past. Maybe with the 10% discount I will join, but hopped it will be around 150$/yearly
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: seris81 on April 24, 2017, 04:08:53 PM

Here you sell eas?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: dutchie on April 24, 2017, 07:07:52 PM

Here you sell eas?
Are you really serious with all your silly questions?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: reinerh on April 24, 2017, 09:41:37 PM

Here you sell eas?
Are you really serious with all your silly questions?

dutchie,

its another robot posting, i see them all over anymore, especially the broker section.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: seris81 on April 24, 2017, 10:48:41 PM

Here you sell eas?
Are you really serious with all your silly questions?

Your questions are the best ...sure  ;D
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: dutchie on April 25, 2017, 06:35:37 PM
So, please Donna ban this irritating seris81 user asap!
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Humble Trader's Fx on April 25, 2017, 07:20:39 PM

Here you sell eas?

Yes, we also sell, potatoes, tomatoes, and lots of carrots.
Send us the money$.

We need a bit of humor. ;)

Regards,
Ilios Ellas
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: 999cjb on April 25, 2017, 07:28:51 PM

Here you sell eas?

Yes, we also sell, potatoes, tomatoes, and lots of carrots.
Send us the money$.

We need a bit of humor. ;)

Regards,
Ilios Ellas

I am sure the poor guy's keyboard just didn't print the P at the front. Perhaps we could all club together to raise $10 to pay for a new keyboard  ;D


Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: dutchie on April 25, 2017, 07:43:55 PM

Here you sell eas?

Yes, we also sell, potatoes, tomatoes, and lots of carrots.
Send us the money$.

We need a bit of humor. ;)

Regards,
Ilios Ellas
The markets may be bad, but i slept like baby, every hour i woke up and cry.  :)  :)  :)
Forex Markets are crazy, every moment one guy buy, second sell and both think that they will make money  ;) :D :)
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Climber on May 26, 2017, 12:58:09 AM
Hi,when this product is purchased do they offer full set up on VPS ?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on May 26, 2017, 07:34:08 AM
Hi,when this product is purchased do they offer full set up on VPS ?

Not sure about this, i guess they'd help you if you have your own VPS - their support is top notch never had a complaint about them over the years. If you are asking if they offer free VPS then the answer to that is no.

If for some reason they can't help you set up on VPS i'll be happy to assist (for free, but would appreciate it if people do use my affiliate links to buy, every little helps support our forum costs and it costs you no more as a buyer).
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Climber on May 29, 2017, 08:38:39 AM
Hi,when this product is purchased do they offer full set up on VPS ?

Not sure about this, i guess they'd help you if you have your own VPS - their support is top notch never had a complaint about them over the years. If you are asking if they offer free VPS then the answer to that is no.

If for some reason they can't help you set up on VPS i'll be happy to assist (for free, but would appreciate it if people do use my affiliate links to buy, every little helps support our forum costs and it costs you no more as a buyer).
Thank you Donna ,will ensure to go through your affiliate link,not sure how to go about this yet but I will find it,Thank you agian.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: donnaforex on May 29, 2017, 10:09:00 AM
It's in the first post of this topic https://donnaforex.com/index.php?topic=19565.0
There is a 10% discount link there too.

Let me know if i can help with anything.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Hansen on August 28, 2017, 12:36:52 PM
new version 2 of the bot just released - does anyone know what is the Difference between "old" FRPEA and new FRPEA2 ?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Chip4Pips on August 28, 2017, 02:57:31 PM
Not a new version; totally different bot. 20 pip SL, 95 pip TP. Backtests looks good, but win rate is low. Given this, looks like a VBO system to me, not a scalper.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: dasher1980 on August 28, 2017, 10:42:39 PM
where did you get this information from? About the new EA?
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: Chip4Pips on August 29, 2017, 06:31:21 AM
where did you get this information from? About the new EA?
Direct email from the developer.
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: corre971 on August 29, 2017, 02:59:48 PM
Their website do not mention the new version
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: reinerh on August 29, 2017, 03:30:39 PM
Not a new version; totally different bot. 20 pip SL, 95 pip TP. Backtests looks good, but win rate is low. Given this, looks like a VBO system to me, not a scalper.

could you please post the backtest ??

curious to take a peek.

thx much
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: corre971 on August 29, 2017, 04:07:52 PM
where did you get this information from? About the new EA?
Direct email from the developer.
If you have a link for this new version or a mfxb account please, post it
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on August 29, 2017, 04:54:00 PM
where did you get this information from? About the new EA?
Direct email from the developer.
If you have a link for this new version or a mfxb account please, post it

Is in the Download sektion , Members Area. myfxbook link and Magic 7496211 .  http://www.myfxbook.com/members/adisbv/forexrealprofitea2/1242167
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: corre971 on August 29, 2017, 06:43:34 PM
where did you get this information from? About the new EA?
Direct email from the developer.
If you have a link for this new version or a mfxb account please, post it

Is in the Download sektion , Members Area. myfxbook link and Magic 7496211 .  http://www.myfxbook.com/members/adisbv/forexrealprofitea2/1242167
Many tnx. Atm only 9 trades. Will be possible to make some evaluations in about 5 - 6 months. But probably not so different from other momentum based eas
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: impifx on September 16, 2017, 01:09:49 PM
Real Profit 2 had a extremely good week. There was a wonderful 235 pip trade with triple risk and a second smaller trade which gave me 18% together :D
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: reinerh on September 16, 2017, 01:22:14 PM
this strategy sure is darn good.

one of the few actually making profits, kudos to adrian :)
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on September 17, 2017, 04:33:38 PM
I add the new EA next Month, my results from FRPEA are very good. But i have for any Strategie a own Chart with own Magic and have add the EA Controller.[img][img
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: atomico on November 17, 2017, 09:03:36 AM
good day to all,

at the end i purchase this bot... i hope this is the right choice for my invest saved money...

about the ea, i can ask to DONNA what are the set used on the live account? and what strategy and risk?
how you think about a medium-high risk for this robot?

on the received document by the team of FRPEA i see that some strategy look better respect other, especially in particular currencies.
EUR and GBP seems the best pair for this bot...

leave all strategy and all currencies is the best way?

best regard

Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: alasdeaguila on November 17, 2017, 01:16:08 PM
Now you can go to the Caribbean and take your pineapple drink  :P if you have 500k ,
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on November 17, 2017, 03:31:51 PM
good day to all,

at the end i purchase this bot... i hope this is the right choice for my invest saved money...

about the ea, i can ask to DONNA what are the set used on the live account? and what strategy and risk?
how you think about a medium-high risk for this robot?

on the received document by the team of FRPEA i see that some strategy look better respect other, especially in particular currencies.
EUR and GBP seems the best pair for this bot...

leave all strategy and all currencies is the best way?

best regard

Hello, put the risk settings from the info you get 3.0-3.5. There are 6 Strategies ! In the Manual you can see which Strategies work with which Pair. You can split the the Pairs and Strategies any with his own Magic number. Sample for USDJPY i open 5 Charts any with own Magic and at any only one Strategie on.
so you have 100% Control

Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: atomico on November 17, 2017, 10:56:19 PM
good day to all,

at the end i purchase this bot... i hope this is the right choice for my invest saved money...

about the ea, i can ask to DONNA what are the set used on the live account? and what strategy and risk?
how you think about a medium-high risk for this robot?

on the received document by the team of FRPEA i see that some strategy look better respect other, especially in particular currencies.
EUR and GBP seems the best pair for this bot...

leave all strategy and all currencies is the best way?

best regard

Hello, put the risk settings from the info you get 3.0-3.5. There are 6 Strategies ! In the Manual you can see which Strategies work with which Pair. You can split the the Pairs and Strategies any with his own Magic number. Sample for USDJPY i open 5 Charts any with own Magic and at any only one Strategie on.
so you have 100% Control

5 different chart??? not only 1 chart for all 5 strategy?

i have placed the ea only in one single chart with preferred strategy activated... i have read wrong the manual...???
Title: Re: Forex Real Profit EA
Post by: wroeckert on November 18, 2017, 01:04:41 PM
good day to all,

at the end i purchase this bot... i hope this is the right choice for my invest saved money...

about the ea, i can ask to DONNA what are the set used on the live account? and what strategy and risk?
how you think about a medium-high risk for this robot?

on the received document by the team of FRPEA i see that some strategy look better respect other, especially in particular currencies.
EUR and GBP seems the best pair for this bot...

leave all strategy and all currencies is the best way?

best regard

Hello, put the risk settings from the info you get 3.0-3.5. There are 6 Strategies ! In the Manual you can see which Strategies work with which Pair. You can split the the Pairs and Strategies any with his own Magic number. Sample for USDJPY i open 5 Charts any with own Magic and at any only one Strategie on.
so you have 100% Control

5 different chart??? not only 1 chart for all 5 strategy?

i have placed the ea only in one single chart with preferred strategy activated... i have read wrong the manual...???

it is right as you did it, but if you set it on different Charts , you can control any Strategie

regards